Bella Pizza & Subs Menu (Update 2026)

Bella Pizza & Subs delivers a standout menu in Atlantic Beach, perfect for those craving authentic New York-style pizza. The offerings range from piping hot slices to full pies, all made fresh daily. Don't miss the two-slice and a drink special for just $8.95 — a deal that keeps locals coming back. Each item brims with flavor; the meatball sub is a fan favorite, known for its juicy meatballs and rich marinara. A variety of hot subs like the Cheesesteak and Chicken Parmigiana add variety for those seeking hearty bites. Calzones and Italian dinners round out the menu, making it easy to find something satisfyingly delicious.

Bella Pizza & Subs Menu image 1
Bella Pizza & Subs Menu image 2
Bella Pizza & Subs Menu image 3
Bella Pizza & Subs Menu image 4

Featured Dishes

Cheese Pizza
Cheese Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Chef Salad
Chef Salad
Supreme Pizza
Supreme Pizza
Turkey Sub
Turkey Sub
Chicken Parmigiana
Chicken Parmigiana
Meat Lovers Pizza
Meat Lovers Pizza
Turkey and Cheese Hoagie
Turkey and Cheese Hoagie
Slice of Pie
Slice of Pie
Meatball Hero
Meatball Hero
Roasted Turkey
Roasted Turkey
Garlic Bread with Cheese
Garlic Bread with Cheese
Pizza with Extra Sauce & Sausage
Pizza with Extra Sauce & Sausage
Peppers
Peppers
Cheesesteak the Works
Cheesesteak the Works
Pepperoni and Meatball Pizza
Pepperoni and Meatball Pizza
Bella Pizza & Subs

Bella Pizza & Subs Interior, Food, Ambiance

While Bella Pizza & Subs lacks seating, it embraces a casual, no-frills takeout environment. The charm lies in the laid-back, community-focused vibe where customers often interact and share recommendations. The mouth-watering aroma of fresh pizza fills the air, guiding hungry patrons in from the Atlantic Beach Causeway. To enjoy the food, simply grab your order to go and bask in the sun or picnic on the beach nearby. Local residents love this spot for quick bites before heading to the ocean, making it a staple in the Atlantic Beach food scene.

Bella Pizza & Subs

About Bella Pizza & Subs Food and Specialties

At Bella Pizza & Subs, the focus remains on quality and tradition. The dough for their New York-style pizza is made fresh every day, creating a perfect foundation for cheese and toppings. The meatball parmigiana sub stands out, packed with flavor and served hot. Diners can also indulge in a variety of calzones, including pepperoni and ham, each stuffed generously with ingredients. For those looking for something lighter, the Italian Chef Salad offers a refreshing balance. The average dish prices hover around $7.71, making delicious Italian food accessible to everyone in the community.

Bella Pizza & Subs

Bella Pizza & Subs commits to serving quality food without the frills. Specializing in New York style pizza, the restaurant focuses on freshness using quality ingredients. Each slice reflects a dedication to artistry in pizza making, ensuring customers savor the familiar tastes of home. The vision behind Bella lies in creating a communal space where everyone, from families to friends, can enjoy honest food quickly. Emphasizing takeout and convenience, Bella fosters connections among locals while catering to the high volume of visitors during peak tourist seasons. It's this blend of tradition and community spirit that keeps locals returning for their favorite pies and subs.